This is a little experiment inspired by Psycon 2024 in Chicago, and the fellow psychos I met there (especially one in particular. You know who you are :). Meeting those psychos renewed my enthusiasm for this silly but still great show. I'm now doing a rewatch while listening to Tim and Maggie's podcast and doing a tier-list / episode review hybrid, and just diving in whole hog! Really hoping Psych 4 sees the light of day!
Top tier S tier:
S2E01 - American Duos
S2E13 - Lights, Camera... Homicidio
S2E15 - Black and Tan: A Crime of Fashion
S5E02 - Last Night Gus
S7E03 - Lassie Jerky
S7E05 - 100 Clues
S7E08 - Right Turn or Left for Dead
S7E11 - Office Space
S8E01 - Lock, Stock, Some Smoking Barrels and Burton Guster's...